Wednesday, January 29, 2020

Same Shit, Different Century


I propose to you a discussion on the fierce political weapon of comedy. Brilliant, delicious, uncomfortable; all these words describe the beautiful power of feminist humor. When misfortunate  patriarchal conditions continue to loom overhead like a threatening thunder cloud, it seems like insightful satire is necessary to maintain a grasp on sanity. The feminist rallying cry "the personal is political," stresses that things that effect women exclusively such as reproductive rights, LGBT+ issues, equal pay, etc. are worth public discussion. Beginning with unique personal experiences can create the foundation or platform for larger systematic issues. The trajectory from the Women's Liberation movement to Women Strike for Peace against HUAC to the Women's Marches of today emphasize the growing protest culture.  The punch up against authority and speaking the truth is an empowering tactic through a common force: laughter. Gray's discussion on "Women and Laughter" suggests that there is inherent power in silence, and therefore the breaking of it. Radical strategies create routes to alternative comedy that commands attention (Gray 15).

"President Wilson, How long do you advise us to wait?" A banner proclaiming this message is held by a group of women at a march for suffrage. Finger pointing tactics advance claims to simply point out indescretion. Mrs. Banks song "Sister Suffragettes" from Mary Poppins also comes to mind. "We're clearly soldiers in petticoats, and dauntless crusaders for women's votes. Though we adore men individually, we agree that as a group they're rather stupid" A daunting theme in popular culture of the early 20th century was the subversion of male and female roles. Cartoons and advertisements depicted women hurrying out the door to vote while the husband handled the household duties.

In the 1960's, amidst the fears of communism, the Women Strike for Peace movement used the powerful rhetoric of maternalism in justifying their activism. It is unique to chart the spectrum women can identify with domesticity. The stroller pushing housewives protested outside the Capitol building, and used sarcastic naiveté against male rigidity to create an "I Love Lucy" style banter against the committee. They protested in their Sunday dresses and white gloves and walked hand in hand with their children to each trial. This mobilization had an unprecedented internalization of the feminine mystique, however it appears as evidence of sarcastic, subversive humor to undermine male superstition.

From pink pussy hats to bra burning, modern feminist movements such as the Women's Marches use protest signage to embrace political humor. I do implore you to check out some of these signs. I can't fit them all in this document (search). It is fascinating to analyze the similarities in differences in the waves of movements, particularly the usage of media influence. The political cartoons of suffragettes, the broadcasted protests of HUAC, and social media influence of modern feminists emphasize that concept of breaking silence in an influential and strategized way. The fertile terrain of cultural experimentation has been necessary in feminist popularization. Success has been moderately achieved due to the commonality of humor, a fundamental human characteristic we can all identify with. To conclude with commentary from Gray, "Jokes are the bridge." "... anarchy and contradiction are, in any area of comic discourse, healthy symptoms" (Gray, 15).







9 comments:

  1. Kelsey, I love this post. I adore the use the images in your post and their strategic placement. I think you're absolutely right to say that comedy and speaking out is one of our most valuable weapons as women to use against all those who put us down. This post reminded me of the point made in one of our articles (which I've perused to try to find the exact quote and article but gave up out of frustration...) about how if men make us cry, we should in cry briefly and then resume our normal day OR we could cry in front of them because it freaks them out. We hold the power to make men uncomfortable merely by crying in front of them (cue malicious snicker with a evil, plotting look behind the eyes). There is power in our silence and noncompliance just as much as their is power in our refusal to stay quiet and comply with whatever were told to do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really enjoy how there is an unspoken spectrum of these ideas: silence and protest. They are both equally strong and objective. I enjoy signage specifically because of how women have recognized it as a tool of power. With the increased flux of social media activity, images of the funniest signs make their way across the internet in a flurry. One that comes to mind was a anti- Trump protest that took place in Shepherdstown and I spotted a sign that said, "Mike Pence listens to Nickelback." My apologies if you enjoy them, but there is something so irreverent and silly about it that has made its stamp on my brain.

      Delete
  2. Kelsey,
    Similarly with Hannah, I loved the use of images in your post and thought they were able to visually tie into your argument extremely well. I think it is interesting how humor is often a tactic used by women to send a message into the world. Your argument also shows how this strategy has been around since women have been protesting. It reminds me of Fanny Fern's use of protest in her articles and how she was almost able to cover them up with her "normal" posts in the newspaper.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's great that you tie in different pop culture references to emphasize your main point. I especially love your reference to the Mary Poppins song "Sister Suffragettes" because I sang that song all of the time when I was little, before I even knew what the message of the song was! We need more feminist messages embedded in pop culture so future generations will subliminally view gender equality as the best hope for the future.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kelsey,
    First I would like to say I have never related to anything more than with your title! I love it! You were able to sum up so much with just 4 words, "Same Shit, different century"! I also throughly enjoyed your inclusion of the pictures from the different century, it is a great testament to the sexualization had and still have in media. Also, loved the protesting picture! The creativity, the drive and the power these women have and utilize to drive such inspiring and challenging statements! I love it!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great post and comments, folks!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love the title on this so much! It's sad how accurate it is though, that us as women in the 21st century are having to deal with the same shit as what the original feminists had to deal with to a certain degree. Using humor as a weapon against the patriarchy is amazing, and I personally love using the rallying cry of "The personal is political." I hope that one day these issues are fixed, and being able to say that "I am a feminist" will be something to be proud of and revered for.

    ReplyDelete
  7. When I saw the title I was immediately like "Oh, DEFINITELY reading this one." This is so great! Your images are so necessary and beneficial to your post, and the idea of humor as a weapon for women is so powerful. I love it. Definitely the same shit in a different century.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This one was SO relatable, and that title was the hot tea spilling all over the cold, hardened truth.
    I've found myself laughing during the hardest moments, while crying or just thinking of something to say in hopes it will better the situation or the way I'm feeling. Most times it does one or the other, unfortunately not both.
    The part you wrote about the Feminist Rallying Cry and just how significantly personal things carry into political situations for women all over in SO many situations we face really connected with me.
    This has also made me think about just how many things haven't changed for women throughout time to the present. How, even during our lowest we often still manage to squeak a laugh through for our wellbeing, our sanity.
    The pictures were just an added plus to the powerful message written above, allover amazing job Kelsey. This was definitely one of my favorites to read.

    ReplyDelete