My idea for my major project was in the back of my mind ever since we learned about Amy Poehler’s iconic quote, “I don’t f*cking care if you like it.” Straight, white men aren’t just the power class in everyday life, it extends to the comedy industry too (what a refreshing twist). I wanted to look at how male approval has affected women in comedy. I also explored how it extends to other aspects of women’s lives and, more importantly, why it isn’t needed. I used the work and experiences of Tina Fey, Amy Poehler, and Ali Wong to back me up. I also used a little help from Barreca’s “good girl” piece. Fey, Poehler, and Wong have one thing in common: they aren’t looking for anyone’s approval. Their difference from everyone else has helped them make names for themselves, and they have stayed true to themselves no matter what.
I started with where we got the notion that women aren’t funny. I googled the phrase and literally 290 million results came up in less than one second. I looked at an article by Bitch Media that gave an abridged history of the claim. Turns out, a playwright named William Congreve was one of the first to publish something on the topic. He said, “I must confess I have never made an observation of what I apprehend to be true humor in women…Perhaps passions are too powerful in that sex to let humor have its course; or maybe by reason of their natural coldness, humor cannot exert itself to that extravagant degree, which is does in the male sex.” Yuck! He wasn’t alone, and throughout the rest of history men have repeatedly tried to push this belief onto others. Some even claimed men “need” to be funny for the purposes of getting women to have sex with them.
Starting with Tina Fey, queen of abolishing beauty standards. Her list of what women must possess to be considered attractive, and her counter-list of all the ones that oppose that, is super important. We can’t live our lives expecting to check all these unrealistic boxes. Then, in an interview with David Letterman, in which he continually tries to praise an SNL sketch she had done, Fey insists on critiquing herself. This shows that just because a well-known man in the industry approves of her work, doesn’t make it good enough for her. Amy Poehler stresses the importance of working for yourself. Probably my favorite chapter in Yes Please was “Treat Your Career Like a Bad Boyfriend.” In it, Poehler describes how your career not only doesn’t owe you anything, but won’t give you anything. She understands the importance of working for no one but yourself, and it’s something we can’t forget. Your career will never serve you, and neither will the opinions of other people. Last but certainly not least, we have Ali Wong. Wong not only had to face the hurdles of being a minority in the comedy industry, she also had family struggles and expectations to abolish. She discusses the pressure of her culture, and how she went against what her family wanted for her. Her father regularly celebrated the accomplishments of Asian Americans. However when she expressed her desire to move to New York and pursue stand-up comedy, those Asian Americans were an exception, and the same would surely not happen for her.
All of these women have proved so many people wrong. They exemplify how important it is to stay true to you, and never dim your light for anyone. Whether it be in your career, your education, or your daily life, never stop putting yourself first. Do your thing and don’t care who likes it!
This was so easy to read because I adore your writing style and the tiny jokes and side remarks you include! The idea of male approval is so complex, and you did a great job explaining the different ways it affects women. Great project idea!
ReplyDeleteUnnecessary male approval is such an intriguing idea to pursue! Women are told that they need to seek male approval in everything they do when this could not be further from the truth. It's just another way to treat women as an object or a subcategory. Really cool project, Alison!
ReplyDeleteYou are very right when it comes to that quote, YUCK! I have also always wondered where this idea originated, and as I read that snippet I thought to myself that all of the reasons he gave for women not being "funny" are most likely due to women trying to appear "ladylike" and adhere to the expectations society has of them, so they don't get shunned or executed or accused of being a witch. Ugh, hypocrisy and impossible standards. Also, I loved the list sections in Tina Fey's book and I am so glad you incorporated them into your project, they are simple but, boy, do they speak volumes! I love this project, and I love that Fey publicly breaks the notion that our standards for ourselves are based on a man's approval. Awesome job, it was so great to have a class with you!
ReplyDeleteJust like everyone else is saying this was a really cool idea for a project. Men give women all kinds of unnecessary judgment and constantly think we need their approval. I think this does a great job of contributing back to the class discussion and showing that men are always judging women. Great work!
ReplyDeleteWow, that quote you included of the "first publication" of the idea that women aren't funny really hurt my soul. I agree with you and Izzy that "YUCK" is an appropriate response to that hogwash. The part about women having a "natural coldness" is just complete bullshit too, as women are almost always overcompensating, smiling all the time, because of comments like this. Women are afraid of being called "angry" or having a "RBF" and are often "sweet" to counteract that, so it makes absolutely no sense to call women "cold." In fact, women are usually pretty nurturing and warm, especially mothers, so his observation is just baseless. Women were probably only "cold" to him because he was gross.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading this post. I can’t believe there were/are men that think they need to be funny to have sex with women. Like seriously?! Women are hilarious all on their own and if a man think he has to be the funny women to get laid then I kind of hope he never does. Personally “I don’t fucking care if you like it” will forever now be my favorite line ever spoken. It’s brilliant. All three of these women were great choices to discuss and all of them did equally amazing things for women in comedy. This was a great post.
ReplyDeleteI found many of these themes with my project! I loved when Poehler said "I don't f*cking care if you like it" in front of Fallon and truly took stand for what she believed in. I think that your project helps the reader have a better understanding of the realities of comedy and just a few of the problems that are involved with it. I hope that certain jokes become less popular as they are ridiculous and that women can have more of a presence.
ReplyDelete*aPPLAUDS* Dang, that was so empowering!! Mmmm, so good!!
ReplyDeleteWow, that ending just fired me up. Gosh. Okay, so first of all, I love everything about the concept of your project. Secondly, this has so much good sass that I'm just getting riled up, which is one of my favorite aspects of this class, so thank you for letting me feel riled up at approximately 9:56 PM in the comfort of my home - I was getting too peaceful and I want to feel indignant about the treatment of women! (Note: not sarcasm - I genuinely love getting riled up like this because it makes me feel like my words and punches could just blow down walls in society. Love this feeling of empowerment and wanting to make a change!) Overall, I genuinely wish I could see your project!! I'm sure you have AMAZING points in there, and I want to continue feeling this motivated to change the world!
My anger at heterosexual white men will never see an end I'm realizing since this prejudice against women has been happening long before I was born and will continue to happen long after I'm gone. Your post was amazing but was also very emotion-inducing in the best way possible. It makes the reader (at least it did for me) to evaluate just how much men have restricted women in society for every section of a woman's life and it stirs up a lot of emotions, whether they be good or bad. I have loved having class with you this semester and I hope you have a phenomenal summer!
ReplyDelete